Transmon Physics
Quantizing a circuit: the Cooper-pair box and the transmon regime.
Why does a millimeter-scale circuit obey the Schrödinger equation, and why did adding a big capacitor to a fragile qubit make it one of the most coherent? This lesson quantizes a circuit from its Lagrangian, maps the Cooper-pair box onto a particle in a periodic potential, and shows that the transmon's protection is a tunneling effect: its sensitivity to charge is the width of a Bloch band.
What you’ll learn
- Quantize a lumped circuit from its Lagrangian and derive the Cooper-pair-box Hamiltonian .
- Map the spectrum onto Bloch bands and derive the scaling of the charge dispersion from the instanton action.
- State Koch et al.'s asymptotic formulas for the levels, the anharmonicity and the charge dispersion, and use them for design.
- Analyze flux-tunable transmons, sweet spots and the main and mechanisms, and place the transmon among alternative superconducting qubits.
Quantizing a circuit
Lumped superconducting circuits are quantized like mechanical systems (Devoret 1995; Vool & Devoret 2017). Take node fluxes as coordinates: capacitors contribute kinetic energy, inductors and junctions potential energy.
A junction (critical current , capacitance ) shunted by a capacitor , with a gate capacitor to a voltage source , and . Constant terms are dropped.
The Legendre transform; is the charge conjugate to the node flux .
Count charge in Cooper pairs and flux in units of . With , . (The sign of is a convention; only its value modulo 1 matters.)
Because . In the phase representation, .
Exact spectrum: Bloch bands and charge dispersion
In the charge basis the Hamiltonian is tridiagonal, . In the phase basis it is Mathieu's equation, solved exactly by Mathieu characteristic values (Koch et al. 2007). The physics is clearest after a gauge transformation.
The phase representation.
This substitution removes from the Hamiltonian ...
... at the price of a twisted boundary condition. Read as the position of a particle of "mass" in the periodic potential : this is Bloch's theorem, with playing the role of quasimomentum.
Each transmon level is a Bloch band. In the transmon regime the wells are deep and the tight-binding approximation applies: the bandwidth, which is the charge dispersion , is set by the amplitude for tunneling from one well to the next, .
Identify the effective mass, with and dimensionless variables.
The WKB (instanton) action for tunneling under the barrier between neighboring minima of .
Using .
The tunneling amplitude, and hence the charge dispersion, is exponentially small in , times an algebraic prefactor that grows with because higher levels sit closer to the top of the barrier.
| Charge dispersion of | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | 1.97 GHz | GHz | 63 MHz |
| 20 | 2.89 GHz | GHz | 4.4 MHz |
| 50 | 4.74 GHz | GHz | 10 kHz |
| 80 | 6.06 GHz | GHz | 0.09 kHz |
A design moves from to . By roughly what factor does the exponential factor in the charge dispersion change?
- It halves
- It decreases by about
- It decreases by
- It increases, because is larger
Show the answer
B. It decreases by about
and , so the factor drops by , about 55 times. The algebraic prefactor grows a little, so the net suppression of is somewhat less, about 30 times.
Anharmonicity, tunability and sweet spots
The leading-order result is slightly too small in magnitude: the exact values in the table exceed it because the next corrections are suppressed only by powers of . Design usually starts from target values of and :
You want GHz with MHz. Using , what do you need, in GHz?
Show the answer
16.9 GHz
GHz, so GHz and . Exact diagonalization with these values gives GHz and MHz. Since , this fixes the critical current at about 34 nA, and hence the junction's oxide thickness and area.
To make the frequency tunable, replace the junction by a SQUID: two junctions in a loop threaded by an external flux . The effective Josephson energy becomes
Losses and the coherence budget
Relaxation rates add over channels, . It is convenient to write each channel as a quality factor, , and the dielectric part as a participation-weighted sum, , where is the fraction of the qubit's electric energy stored in region (the substrate and the metal–air, metal–substrate and substrate–air interfaces) and is its loss tangent.
| Mechanism | Signature | Typical remedy |
|---|---|---|
| TLS defects | dips at specific frequencies that wander in time (spectral diffusion) | materials and surface treatment; retuning the qubit frequency |
| Quasiparticles | parity switching; correlated bursts after radiation impacts | infrared shielding; gap engineering; phonon traps; radiation shielding |
| Purcell decay and radiation | limited by coupling to lines, resonators and box modes | Purcell filters; careful packaging |
| Flux noise () | degrades away from the sweet spot | sweet spots; echo and dynamical decoupling |
| Thermal photons | limited by residual photons in the readout resonator | line attenuation and filtering |
import numpy as np
def transmon_levels(EJ, EC, ng=0.0, ncut=15, k=4):
"""Lowest k energies (relative to the ground state) of H = 4 EC (n - ng)^2 - EJ cos(phi)."""
n = np.arange(-ncut, ncut + 1)
H = np.diag(4 * EC * (n - ng) ** 2)
H -= 0.5 * EJ * (np.eye(len(n), k=1) + np.eye(len(n), k=-1))
E = np.linalg.eigvalsh(H)
return E[:k] - E[0]
EC = 0.25 # E_C / h in GHz
for ratio in (10, 20, 50, 80):
E = transmon_levels(ratio * EC, EC)
f01, alpha = E[1], E[2] - 2 * E[1]
print(f"EJ/EC = {ratio:3d}: f01 = {f01:.3f} GHz, alpha = {1e3 * alpha:.0f} MHz")Exact diagonalization in the charge basis, truncated at , which is ample for these parameters. Repeating with ng=0.5 and comparing gives the charge dispersion listed in the table.
Key takeaways
- Circuits are quantized from their Lagrangian; for the Cooper-pair box, with .
- The offset charge is a Bloch quasimomentum, and the charge dispersion is a tight-binding bandwidth, , whose exponent is the instanton action between wells.
- To leading order, and ; the relative anharmonicity falls only as .
- SQUID-tunable transmons trade first-order flux-noise immunity (kept only at sweet spots) for tunability; DRAG pulses manage leakage from the weak anharmonicity.
- is dominated by dielectric (TLS) loss at surfaces, plus quasiparticles, Purcell decay and radiation; materials science sets the frontier.
Check yourself
In the interactive lesson these are scored with your confidence, and what you miss comes back for review.
In circuit quantization of the Cooper-pair box, which pair of variables is canonically conjugate?
- Current and voltage
- The junction phase and the Cooper-pair number , with
- Flux and current
- Charge and voltage
Show the answer
B. The junction phase and the Cooper-pair number , with
is conjugate to the node flux ; rescaled, and satisfy , because .
In the Bloch-band picture of the transmon, what plays the role of quasimomentum, and what sets the bandwidth?
- ; the amplitude for tunneling between neighboring wells of ,
- ; the anharmonicity
- ; the charging energy
- ; thermal fluctuations
Show the answer
A. ; the amplitude for tunneling between neighboring wells of ,
A gauge transformation moves into the boundary condition , exactly as quasimomentum appears in Bloch's theorem. Tight-binding bandwidths are tunneling amplitudes, here exponentially small in the instanton action .
Why is a flux-tunable transmon usually parked at its maximum frequency when idle?
- Its anharmonicity is largest there
- Its charge dispersion vanishes there
- Its frequency is first-order insensitive to flux noise there,
- It is farthest from its readout resonator there
Show the answer
C. Its frequency is first-order insensitive to flux noise there,
At an extremum of the linear coupling to flux noise vanishes, leaving only a weaker second-order sensitivity, so pure dephasing from flux noise is minimized.
In the transmon regime, how do the charge dispersion and the anharmonicity behave as grows?
- Both decrease exponentially
- Both decrease algebraically
- decreases algebraically and exponentially
- decreases exponentially, while stays close to (relative anharmonicity )
Show the answer
D. decreases exponentially, while stays close to (relative anharmonicity )
This asymmetry is the whole point of the transmon. Charge sensitivity is a tunneling effect, exponentially suppressed; anharmonicity comes from the quartic term and decreases only algebraically relative to .
Further reading
- J. Koch, T. M. Yu, J. Gambetta, A. A. Houck, D. I. Schuster, J. Majer, A. Blais, M. H. Devoret, S. M. Girvin & R. J. Schoelkopf, "Charge-insensitive qubit design derived from the Cooper pair box", Physical Review A 76, 042319 (2007).
- V. Bouchiat, D. Vion, P. Joyez, D. Esteve & M. H. Devoret, "Quantum coherence with a single Cooper pair", Physica Scripta T76, 165 (1998); Y. Nakamura, Yu. A. Pashkin & J. S. Tsai, "Coherent control of macroscopic quantum states in a single-Cooper-pair box", Nature 398, 786 (1999).
- U. Vool & M. Devoret, "Introduction to quantum electromagnetic circuits", International Journal of Circuit Theory and Applications 45, 897 (2017).
- F. Motzoi, J. M. Gambetta, P. Rebentrost & F. K. Wilhelm, "Simple pulses for elimination of leakage in weakly nonlinear qubits", Physical Review Letters 103, 110501 (2009).
- P. Krantz et al., "A quantum engineer's guide to superconducting qubits", Applied Physics Reviews 6, 021318 (2019).