Simple Algorithm
Quantum Computing · Rydberg State · 28 min

Dispersive Readout & Cryogenics

Measuring a qubit through a resonator, at millikelvin.

To read a superconducting qubit you never look at the qubit. You bounce a few microwave photons off a resonator whose frequency depends on the qubit's state, and amplify that faint signal through a chain of amplifiers stretching from 10 millikelvin to room temperature. This lesson derives the dispersive Hamiltonian, the trade-offs that limit readout speed and fidelity, and the cryogenic environment that makes it all possible.

What you’ll learn

  • Derive the dispersive Hamiltonian from the Jaynes–Cummings model, and the transmon dispersive shift χ=g2ΔαΔ+α\chi = \frac{g^2}{\Delta}\frac{\alpha}{\Delta+\alpha}.
  • Compute the pointer-state separation and measurement-induced dephasing, and show that κ=2χ\kappa = 2\chi maximizes the signal rate at fixed photon number.
  • Quantify Purcell decay, and explain Purcell filters, quantum-limited amplification and the added-noise bound.
  • Describe the dilution refrigerator, estimate dephasing from residual thermal photons, and explain the quasiparticle and TLS limits.

From Jaynes–Cummings to the dispersive limit

HJCℏ=ωra†a+ωq2 σz+g (a†σ−+a σ+)\frac{H_{\text{JC}}}{\hbar} = \omega_ra^\dagger a+\frac{\omega_q}{2}\,\sigma_z+g\,\big(a^\dagger\sigma^-+a\,\sigma^+\big)
A two-level qubit coupled to a single resonator mode: the Jaynes–Cummings model. Circuit QED realizes it with a transmon and a planar or 3D microwave resonator (Blais et al. 2004; Wallraff et al. 2004).
DerivationSchrieffer–Wolff to second order
  1. U=exp⁡[gΔ(a σ+−a†σ−)],Δ=ωq−ωrU = \exp\Big[\frac{g}{\Delta}\big(a\,\sigma^+-a^\dagger\sigma^-\big)\Big],\qquad\Delta = \omega_q-\omega_r

    A unitary that removes the coupling to first order in λ=g/Δ\lambda = g/\Delta.

  2. UHJCU†≈ωra†a+ωq2 σz+g2Δ(a†a σz+1+σz2)UH_{\text{JC}}U^\dagger\approx\omega_ra^\dagger a+\frac{\omega_q}{2}\,\sigma_z+\frac{g^2}{\Delta}\Big(a^\dagger a\,\sigma_z+\frac{1+\sigma_z}{2}\Big)

    Expand to second order in λ\lambda and drop terms of order gλ2g\lambda^2 and higher.

  3. Hdispℏ=(ωr+χσz)a†a+ωq+χ2 σz,χ=g2Δ\frac{H_{\text{disp}}}{\hbar} = \big(\omega_r+\chi\sigma_z\big)a^\dagger a+\frac{\omega_q+\chi}{2}\,\sigma_z,\qquad\chi = \frac{g^2}{\Delta}

    One term, two readings: the resonator frequency depends on the qubit state (ωr±χ\omega_r\pm\chi), and the qubit frequency depends on the photon number (an ac Stark shift of 2χ2\chi per photon). The Lamb shift χ\chi renormalizes ωq\omega_q.

  4. nˉ≪ncrit=Δ24g2\bar n\ll n_{\text{crit}} = \frac{\Delta^2}{4g^2}

    The expansion requires the photon number to stay well below the critical photon number; beyond it, higher-order terms and eventually measurement-induced transitions appear.

Pointer states, dephasing and the optimal linewidth

Drive the resonator at ωd\omega_d with amplitude ε\varepsilon; it leaks into the measurement line at rate κ\kappa. Conditioned on the qubit state σz=±1\sigma_z = \pm1, the field relaxes to a coherent state ∣β±⟩\ket{\beta_\pm}, a pointer state.

DerivationPointer-state separation and dephasing
  1. β˙±=−i(δ±χ) β±−κ2 β±−iε,δ=ωr−ωd\dot\beta_\pm = -i(\delta\pm\chi)\,\beta_\pm-\frac\kappa2\,\beta_\pm-i\varepsilon,\qquad\delta = \omega_r-\omega_d

    Equation of motion for the mean field, in the frame of the drive.

  2. β±=−iεκ/2+i(δ±χ)  =δ=0  −iεκ/2±iχ,nˉ=∣β±∣2=ε2κ2/4+χ2\beta_\pm = \frac{-i\varepsilon}{\kappa/2+i(\delta\pm\chi)}\;\overset{\delta = 0}{=}\;\frac{-i\varepsilon}{\kappa/2\pm i\chi},\qquad\bar n = \abs{\beta_\pm}^2 = \frac{\varepsilon^2}{\kappa^2/4+\chi^2}

    The steady state, driving midway between the two dressed resonator frequencies.

  3. ∣β+−β−∣2=4χ2 nˉκ2/4+χ2\abs{\beta_+-\beta_-}^2 = \frac{4\chi^2\,\bar n}{\kappa^2/4+\chi^2}

    The distinguishability of the two pointer states. The output field carries this separation away at rate κ\kappa.

  4. Γm=κ2 ∣β+−β−∣2=2κχ2nˉκ2/4+χ2  ⟶χ≪κ  8χ2nˉκ\Gamma_m = \frac\kappa2\,\abs{\beta_+-\beta_-}^2 = \frac{2\kappa\chi^2\bar n}{\kappa^2/4+\chi^2}\;\overset{\chi\ll\kappa}{\longrightarrow}\;\frac{8\chi^2\bar n}{\kappa}

    Measurement-induced dephasing: the qubit's coherence decays at the rate at which which-state information leaks out (Gambetta et al. 2006). Information gain and dephasing are two sides of one process.

  5. ddκ κχ2κ2/4+χ2=0  ⟹  κ=2χ\frac{d}{d\kappa}\,\frac{\kappa\chi^2}{\kappa^2/4+\chi^2} = 0\;\Longrightarrow\;\kappa = 2\chi

    At a fixed photon number nˉ\bar n, itself capped by ncritn_{\text{crit}} and by measurement-induced transitions, the information rate ∝κ∣β+−β−∣2\propto\kappa\abs{\beta_+-\beta_-}^2 is maximized at κ=2χ\kappa = 2\chi. Readout resonators are designed near this condition.

Check your understanding

At a fixed mean photon number, you can choose the resonator linewidth κ\kappa for a given χ\chi. Which choice maximizes the rate at which you learn the qubit state?

  1. κ≪χ\kappa\ll\chi, so that the pointer states are maximally separated
  2. κ=2χ\kappa = 2\chi
  3. κ≫χ\kappa\gg\chi, so that photons leave as fast as possible
  4. It does not matter: only nˉ\bar n counts
Show the answer

B. κ=2χ\kappa = 2\chi

Information leaves at a rate ∝κ∣β+−β−∣2∝κχ2/(κ2/4+χ2)\propto\kappa\abs{\beta_+-\beta_-}^2\propto\kappa\chi^2/(\kappa^2/4+\chi^2), which peaks at κ=2χ\kappa = 2\chi. A very narrow resonator separates the pointer states well but releases the information slowly; a very broad one releases photons quickly but barely separates the states.

Purcell decay and filters

The dressed qubit is slightly photon-like: in the dispersive frame its excitation carries an admixture (g/Δ)2(g/\Delta)^2 of resonator photon, which leaks out at rate κ\kappa. This is Purcell decay:

ΓPurcell≈κ(gΔ)2\Gamma_{\text{Purcell}}\approx\kappa\Big(\frac{g}{\Delta}\Big)^2
The two-level dispersive estimate. Houck et al. (2008) measured and modeled Purcell decay of transmons, including corrections from the full electromagnetic environment.
Predict before you look

With κ/2π=4\kappa/2\pi = 4 MHz and g/Δ=0.05g/\Delta = 0.05, what Purcell-limited T1T_1 does the formula predict, in μs?

Show the answer

16 μs

Γ=2π×4 MHz×0.0025=2π×10\Gamma = 2\pi\times4\ \text{MHz}\times0.0025 = 2\pi\times10 kHz, so T1=1/Γ≈16T_1 = 1/\Gamma\approx16 μs, far below the hundreds of μs that good materials allow. Fast readout (large κ\kappa, and large χ∝g2\chi\propto g^2) and long T1T_1 pull in opposite directions.

The way out is a Purcell filter: a bandpass element, such as a second resonator or a filter built into the readout line, placed between the readout resonator and the environment. It is transparent at ωr\omega_r but reflective at ωq\omega_q (Reed et al. 2010; Jeffrey et al. 2014), suppressing ΓPurcell\Gamma_{\text{Purcell}} by a large factor so that κ\kappa can be made large for fast readout. Several readout resonators at different frequencies can share one filter and one feedline: this is how readout is frequency-multiplexed.

At ten millikelvin

All of this happens inside a dilution refrigerator. A pulse-tube cryocooler precools stages to about 50 K and 4 K; below that, a mixture of helium-3 and helium-4 provides continuous cooling, as helium-3 atoms are driven across the phase boundary between a helium-3-rich and a dilute phase in the mixing chamber, which reaches about 10 mK. The cooling power there is only of order microwatts to tens of microwatts, so every wire matters.

Control lines bring signals from room temperature, and thermal noise with them: at 300 K and 7 GHz a line carries about kBT/ℏω≈900k_BT/\hbar\omega\approx900 photons per mode. Attenuators at successive stages, totaling about 60 dB, bring this down, while the output line uses circulators and isolators so that amplifier noise does not travel back to the qubits. Infrared-absorbing filters, light-tight radiation shields and magnetic shields complete the setup.

DerivationDephasing from residual thermal photons
  1. nth=1eℏωr/kBTeff−1n_{\text{th}} = \frac{1}{e^{\hbar\omega_r/k_BT_{\text{eff}}}-1}

    The Bose–Einstein occupation of the readout mode at its effective temperature.

  2. Γφth≈nth κ 4χ2κ2+4χ2(nth≪1)\Gamma_\varphi^{\text{th}}\approx n_{\text{th}}\,\kappa\,\frac{4\chi^2}{\kappa^2+4\chi^2}\qquad(n_{\text{th}}\ll1)

    Each thermal photon that enters and leaves the resonator imprints a random phase on the qubit through the dispersive shift (Clerk & Utami 2007; Sears et al. 2012).

  3. χ≫κ:  Γφth≈nth κ;χ≪κ:  Γφth≈4χ2nthκ\chi\gg\kappa:\ \ \Gamma_\varphi^{\text{th}}\approx n_{\text{th}}\,\kappa;\qquad\chi\ll\kappa:\ \ \Gamma_\varphi^{\text{th}}\approx\frac{4\chi^2n_{\text{th}}}{\kappa}

    In the strong-dispersive limit every passing photon fully measures the qubit; in the weak limit each one only partly does.

Predict before you look

A readout resonator has κ/2π=1\kappa/2\pi = 1 MHz, χ≫κ\chi\gg\kappa and a residual thermal occupation nth=10−3n_{\text{th}} = 10^{-3}. What pure-dephasing time TφT_\varphi does this cause, in μs?

Show the answer

160 μs

Γφ=nthκ=10−3×2π×106 s−1≈6.3×103 s−1\Gamma_\varphi = n_{\text{th}}\kappa = 10^{-3}\times2\pi\times10^6\ \text{s}^{-1}\approx6.3\times10^3\ \text{s}^{-1}, so Tφ≈160T_\varphi\approx160 μs. An occupation of 10−310^{-3} at 7 GHz corresponds to an effective temperature of only about 50 mK, yet it would cap T2T_2 at the level of good transmons. Hence the care taken over attenuation and filtering.

ThreatMechanismMitigation
Quasiparticlespair-breaking radiation (stray infrared light, radioactivity, cosmic rays) creates excess quasiparticles, whose tunneling causes T1T_1 loss and parity switchinglight-tight shielding and infrared filters; gap engineering; quasiparticle and phonon traps; radiation shielding or operating underground (Vepsäläinen et al. 2020)
Correlated error burstsa high-energy impact floods the chip with phonons and quasiparticles, raising error rates on many qubits at once (McEwen et al. 2022)phonon downconversion and trapping layers; gap engineering; chip design
TLS defectsresonant two-level defects in amorphous oxides absorb energy and wander in frequency, so T1T_1 fluctuates over time (Klimov et al. 2018)materials and surface chemistry; monitoring and frequency retuning
Wiring heat loadeach qubit needs roughly one to three lines; conduction and dissipation in attenuators load the cold stagesflexible flat cables; multiplexed readout; cryogenic CMOS or single-flux-quantum control

Key takeaways

  • In the dispersive limit, H≈(ωr+χσz)a†a+12(ωq+χ)σzH\approx(\omega_r+\chi\sigma_z)a^\dagger a+\tfrac12(\omega_q+\chi)\sigma_z: a QND coupling valid for nˉ≪ncrit=Δ2/4g2\bar n\ll n_{\text{crit}} = \Delta^2/4g^2; for transmons, χ=g2ΔαΔ+α\chi = \frac{g^2}{\Delta}\frac{\alpha}{\Delta+\alpha}.
  • Pointer states separate as ∣β+−β−∣2=4χ2nˉ/(κ2/4+χ2)\abs{\beta_+-\beta_-}^2 = 4\chi^2\bar n/(\kappa^2/4+\chi^2); the same information flow dephases the qubit at Γm=κ2∣β+−β−∣2\Gamma_m = \frac\kappa2\abs{\beta_+-\beta_-}^2, and κ=2χ\kappa = 2\chi maximizes the signal rate at fixed nˉ\bar n.
  • Purcell decay, κ(g/Δ)2\kappa(g/\Delta)^2, ties readout speed to T1T_1; Purcell filters and near-quantum-limited amplifiers (JPAs and TWPAs, approaching Caves' half-photon bound) ease the trade-offs.
  • Dilution refrigerators reach about 10 mK, but effective temperatures, thermal photons (Γφ≈nthκ\Gamma_\varphi\approx n_{\text{th}}\kappa), quasiparticles, radiation and TLS defects set the real coherence limits.

Check yourself

In the interactive lesson these are scored with your confidence, and what you miss comes back for review.

Question 1

In Hdisp=(ωr+χσz)a†a+12(ωq+χ)σzH_{\text{disp}} = (\omega_r+\chi\sigma_z)a^\dagger a+\tfrac12(\omega_q+\chi)\sigma_z, the term χσza†a\chi\sigma_za^\dagger a means that

  1. only the resonator frequency depends on the qubit state
  2. only the qubit frequency depends on the photon number
  3. both: the resonator shifts by ±χ\pm\chi with the qubit state, and the qubit shifts by 2χ2\chi per photon (ac Stark shift)
  4. the qubit and resonator exchange energy at rate χ\chi
Show the answer

C. both: the resonator shifts by ±χ\pm\chi with the qubit state, and the qubit shifts by 2χ2\chi per photon (ac Stark shift)

The same operator can be grouped either way. The first reading underlies readout; the second explains measurement-induced dephasing and the photon-number splitting of the qubit line.

Question 2

Why does a Purcell filter allow faster readout without sacrificing T1T_1?

  1. It is transparent at the resonator frequency but blocks the environment at the qubit frequency, suppressing Purcell decay while keeping a large κ\kappa
  2. It increases gg
  3. It cools the resonator
  4. It reduces χ\chi
Show the answer

A. It is transparent at the resonator frequency but blocks the environment at the qubit frequency, suppressing Purcell decay while keeping a large κ\kappa

Purcell decay is emission at the qubit frequency through the readout channel. A bandpass filter centered on ωr\omega_r passes the readout signal but presents a mismatched environment at ωq\omega_q, decoupling the qubit from the line.

Question 3

A phase-preserving amplifier with high gain must add, referred to its input, at least

  1. no noise, if it is ideal
  2. half a photon of noise
  3. one photon of noise
  4. kBT/ℏωk_BT/\hbar\omega photons at the refrigerator temperature
Show the answer

B. half a photon of noise

Caves (1982): an amplifier that boosts both quadratures equally must add noise equivalent to at least half a quantum, 12ℏω\tfrac12\hbar\omega, at its input as the gain becomes large. Phase-sensitive amplifiers can amplify one quadrature noiselessly, at the expense of the other.

Question 4

Why can a residual thermal population of only nth∼10−3n_{\text{th}}\sim10^{-3} in the readout resonator matter?

  1. It heats the chip above its superconducting transition
  2. It excites the qubit to ∣1⟩\ket1 directly
  3. It changes the value of χ\chi
  4. In the strong-dispersive regime each passing photon dephases the qubit, so Γφ≈nthκ\Gamma_\varphi\approx n_{\text{th}}\kappa can cap T2T_2 near 100 μs
Show the answer

D. In the strong-dispersive regime each passing photon dephases the qubit, so Γφ≈nthκ\Gamma_\varphi\approx n_{\text{th}}\kappa can cap T2T_2 near 100 μs

With κ/2π∼1\kappa/2\pi\sim1 MHz, nthκ≈6×103 s−1n_{\text{th}}\kappa\approx6\times10^3\ \text{s}^{-1}, so Tφ∼160T_\varphi\sim160 μs, comparable to the coherence of good transmons. Thermal photons dephase the qubit through the dispersive shift without exchanging energy with it.

Further reading

  • A. Blais, R.-S. Huang, A. Wallraff, S. M. Girvin & R. J. Schoelkopf, "Cavity quantum electrodynamics for superconducting electrical circuits: An architecture for quantum computation", Physical Review A 69, 062320 (2004).
  • A. Blais, A. L. Grimsmo, S. M. Girvin & A. Wallraff, "Circuit quantum electrodynamics", Reviews of Modern Physics 93, 025005 (2021).
  • A. A. Clerk, M. H. Devoret, S. M. Girvin, F. Marquardt & R. J. Schoelkopf, "Introduction to quantum noise, measurement, and amplification", Reviews of Modern Physics 82, 1155 (2010).
  • E. Jeffrey et al., "Fast accurate state measurement with superconducting qubits", Physical Review Letters 112, 190504 (2014).
  • P. Krantz et al., "A quantum engineer's guide to superconducting qubits", Applied Physics Reviews 6, 021318 (2019).