Measuring twice, measuring in turn, and disturbance.
Measure a spin along z, then along x, then along z again: the last answer is a coin toss, even though the first one was certain. Sequences of measurements expose exactly how measurement disturbs, and the Lüders rule says precisely what survives.
What you’ll learn
Distinguish the von Neumann and Lüders update rules, and apply the Lüders instrument to degenerate measurements.
Prove that the Lüders instrument is the unique ideal measurement of a sharp observable.
Derive Wigner's formula for sequential outcome probabilities and explain order effects.
Prove Lüders' theorem: measuring A leaves every statistic of B unchanged iff [A,B]=0.
Quantify steering by measurement: N projective steps carry ∣0⟩ to ∣1⟩ with probability cos2N2Nπ≥1−4Nπ2.
Two update rules
For a non-degenerate observable there is nothing to decide: outcome a leaves the eigenvector ∣a⟩. For a degenerate one, A=∑aaPa with rankPa>1, von Neumann (1932) imagined refining A into a non-degenerate observable, so that the state ends up in some basis vector of the eigenspace, which depends on an arbitrary choice of refinement. Lüders (1951) proposed instead to simply project:
ρ⟼Tr(Paρ)PaρPa.
Ideal measurements are Lüders measurements
DerivationProof
Ia(ρ)=j∑KajρKaj†,j∑Kaj†Kaj=Pa
Write each operation in Kraus form. Because the instrument measures A, the Kraus operators of outcome a add up to the projector Pa.
Kaj(I−Pa)=0
For ∣φ⟩ orthogonal to the range of Pa, ∑j∥Kaj∣φ⟩∥2=⟨φ∣Pa∣φ⟩=0, so every Kaj vanishes off the eigenspace.
j∑Kaj∣ψ⟩⟨ψ∣Kaj†=∣ψ⟩⟨ψ∣⟹Kaj∣ψ⟩=caj(ψ)∣ψ⟩
Apply ideality to a pure state ∣ψ⟩=Pa∣ψ⟩. A sum of positive rank-one operators equals a rank-one projector, so every term is proportional to it.
If every vector of a subspace is an eigenvector of Kaj, the eigenvalue cannot depend on the vector (compare ∣u⟩, ∣v⟩ and ∣u⟩+∣v⟩). So Kaj acts on the eigenspace as a scalar.
Tr(Paρ)=1⇒PaρPa=ρ,Tr(Paρ)Tr(PaPaρPa)=1■
Conversely, a state with a certain outcome is supported on the range of Pa, so the Lüders instrument leaves it alone (ideal), and Pa2=Pa makes it repeatable.
Sequences and order effects
Chain Lüders updates, and the probability of a whole sequence of outcomes becomes a single trace, often called Wigner's formula:
The normalizations p(a1), p(a2∣a1), … telescope away. The product Pa1(1)⋯Pan(n) is in general not a projector, which is why sequential statistics are not those of any single projective measurement.
DerivationTwo measurements, two asymmetries
p(a,b)=Tr(QbPaρPaQb)=Tr(PaQbPaρ)
Measure A=∑aaPa, then B=∑bbQb, both with Lüders updates.
b∑p(a,b)=Tr(PaρPa)=Tr(Paρ)
The future does not disturb the past: summing over the later outcome always restores the earlier statistics.
a∑p(a,b)=Tr(QbΛA(ρ))=Tr(Qbρ)in general
The past does disturb the future: an earlier measurement, even with its outcome forgotten, changes later statistics.
When measuring one observable leaves another alone
DerivationProof
Tr(QbΛA(ρ))=Tr(ΛA(Qb)ρ)∀ρ⟺a∑PaQbPa=Qb
ΛA is self-adjoint for the Hilbert–Schmidt inner product, so the condition says that each Qb is a fixed point of the pinching.
PcQb=PcQbPc=QbPc
Multiply the fixed-point equation by Pc on the left, and separately on the right. Orthogonality, PcPa=δcaPc, collapses each sum to a single term.
[Pa,Qb]=0∀a,b⟺[A,B]=0■
Every Qb commutes with every Pa, and spectral projectors commute exactly when the observables do. Conversely, commuting projectors give ∑aPaQbPa=Qb∑aPa=Qb.
In finite dimensions the same conclusion holds for unsharp Lüders operations ρ↦∑kEkρEk, because the fixed points of a unital channel are exactly the operators that commute with all of its Kraus operators. In infinite dimensions this can fail.
Check your understanding
On a qubit, you measure X (Lüders update, outcome forgotten) and then Z. For which initial states are the Z statistics the same as without the X measurement?
All states, because the X outcome is forgotten
Only ∣+⟩ and ∣−⟩
Exactly the states with ⟨Z⟩=0
No states at all, since X and Z do not commute
Show the answer
C. Exactly the states with ⟨Z⟩=0
ΛX maps the Bloch vector (rx,ry,rz) to (rx,0,0), so afterwards ⟨Z⟩=0. The Z statistics are unchanged exactly when rz was already 0: the whole x–y disk, not just ∣±⟩. Lüders' theorem only guarantees that some state is disturbed when [X,Z]=0.
Steering by measurement
Disturbance can be put to work. Measure a qubit N times along axes that turn in equal steps from +z to −z. Whenever every outcome "passes", the state has been dragged from ∣0⟩ to ∣1⟩ without any Hamiltonian at all.
DerivationDragging a state with projective measurements
∣θk⟩=cos2θk∣0⟩+sin2θk∣1⟩,θk=Nkπ,k=1,…,N
Measure {∣θk⟩⟨θk∣,I−∣θk⟩⟨θk∣} in turn, starting from ∣θ0⟩=∣0⟩.
∣⟨θk−1∣θk⟩∣2=cos22Nπ
Neighboring states differ by a Bloch angle π/N, which is half of that in Hilbert space.
Ppass(N)=cos2N2Nπ≥(1−4N2π2)N≥1−4Nπ2
Using cos2x≥1−x2 and Bernoulli's inequality. The failure probability falls like 1/N.
Predict before you look
With N=10 dragging measurements, what is the probability, in percent, that every one of them passes?
Show the answer
78 %
cos20(π/20)=cos20(9∘)≈0.781, about 78%. Compare N=1: 0, since ∣0⟩⊥∣1⟩; N=2: 41, the three-polarizer effect; N=100: about 97.6%. The bound 1−π2/4N gives 75% for N=10.
This is the measurement-only cousin of the quantum Zeno effect: frequent measurement along a fixed axis freezes a slowly evolving state, while measurement along a slowly moving axis drags the state along. Weak measurement and the Zeno effect are developed in the lessons on generalized measurements.
Key takeaways
The Lüders rule ρ↦PaρPa/p(a) keeps coherence inside degenerate eigenspaces. It is the unique ideal measurement of a sharp observable, and it is repeatable.
Sequential probabilities follow Wigner's formula. Later measurements never change earlier statistics, but earlier ones generally change later ones, so order matters.
Lüders' theorem: measuring A leaves all statistics of B unchanged, for every state, iff [A,B]=0.
Repeated measurements can steer a state: N dragging steps succeed with probability cos2N(π/2N)≥1−π2/4N.
Check yourself
In the interactive lesson these are scored with your confidence, and what you miss comes back for review.
Question 1
A qutrit in 21(∣1⟩+∣2⟩) undergoes the Lüders measurement {∣0⟩⟨0∣,∣1⟩⟨1∣+∣2⟩⟨2∣}. What is the state after the second outcome (which is certain)?
Unchanged: 21(∣1⟩+∣2⟩)
∣1⟩ or ∣2⟩, each with probability 21
The mixture 21(∣1⟩⟨1∣+∣2⟩⟨2∣)
∣0⟩
Show the answer
A. Unchanged: 21(∣1⟩+∣2⟩)
The state lies in the range of P=∣1⟩⟨1∣+∣2⟩⟨2∣, so PρP=ρ. The Lüders rule is ideal and leaves it alone.
Question 2
Start in ∣0⟩. Measure X, then Z, both projectively with Lüders updates. What is p(X=−,Z=1)?
0
21
81
41
Show the answer
D.41
p=∣⟨−∣0⟩∣2∣⟨1∣−⟩∣2=21⋅21=41. Without the X measurement, Z=1 would be impossible.
Question 3
Which pair of two-qubit observables can be measured one after the other, in either order and for every state, without changing each other's statistics?
Z⊗I and X⊗I
Z⊗Z and X⊗X
Z⊗Z and X⊗I
X⊗I and Y⊗I
Show the answer
B.Z⊗Z and X⊗X
By Lüders' theorem the criterion is commutation. Z⊗Z and X⊗X anticommute on both tensor factors, so the signs cancel and they commute.
Question 4
What singles out the Lüders instrument among all instruments that measure a sharp observable A?
It is the only repeatable one
It is the only one with a single Kraus operator per outcome
It is the only ideal one: it leaves unchanged every state whose outcome was already certain
It is the only trace-preserving one
Show the answer
C. It is the only ideal one: it leaves unchanged every state whose outcome was already certain
Ideal (minimally disturbing) instruments for a sharp observable are exactly the Lüders instrument. Repeatability alone is weaker: fixed-vector and von Neumann-refinement instruments are repeatable but not ideal.
Further reading
G. Lüders, "Über die Zustandsänderung durch den Meßprozeß", Annalen der Physik (1951); English translation by K. A. Kirkpatrick, "Concerning the state-change due to the measurement process", Annalen der Physik (2006).
J. von Neumann, Mathematische Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik (Springer, 1932); English translation, Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics (Princeton, 1955).
E. P. Wigner, "The problem of measurement", American Journal of Physics 31 (1963).
T. Heinosaari & M. Ziman, The Mathematical Language of Quantum Theory: From Uncertainty to Entanglement (Cambridge, 2012).
B. Skinner, J. Ruhman & A. Nahum, "Measurement-induced phase transitions in the dynamics of entanglement", Physical Review X 9 (2019).