States as Rays: Projective Hilbert Space
Global phase, CP^n and the Fubini–Study metric.
and are different vectors but the same physical state. Take that seriously and the state space stops being a vector space. It becomes complex projective space, a curved manifold with its own natural distance, its own symmetries and its own speed limit.
What you’ll learn
- Define pure states as rays and identify the state space with , with .
- Compute Fubini–Study distances and relate them to fidelity, trace distance and Bloch angles.
- State Wigner's theorem and explain why antiunitary maps such as the universal NOT are unphysical.
- Derive the Anandan–Aharonov speed and the Mandelstam–Tamm bound.
From vectors to rays
Every prediction depends only on rays: and . For , is the Bloch sphere : unit vectors form , and forgetting the phase is the Hopf fibration , whose fibers are circles of global phase. For qubits, has real dimension .
Global phase is unobservable, but a phase is only global relative to a system. Apply conditionally on a control qubit in superposition and it becomes a relative phase of the larger system, hence measurable. That is phase kickback, the engine of phase estimation.
The Fubini–Study metric
Parametrize and differentiate:
Subtract the phase direction:
That is the round metric of a sphere of radius : FS distances are half the Bloch angles , i.e. . Orthogonal states are antipodal () at FS distance .
The FS distance packages the other pure-state measures: fidelity and trace distance . Up to scale it is the unique Riemannian metric on invariant under all unitaries, and in this normalization . The normalized volume is the Haar measure on pure states used in every random-state argument.
What is the Fubini–Study distance between and , in degrees? (Their Bloch vectors are apart.)
Show the answer
45 °
, half the Bloch angle.
Symmetries: Wigner's theorem
Fix an orthonormal basis . Transition probabilities and are preserved, so representatives of the rays again form an orthonormal basis.
The image of has overlap with and and with the rest, so it is . Absorb into :
For with , the image is with and ; preserving the overlap with forces :
Testing against rays such as and shows that the choice cannot vary with or with . So is induced either by a unitary or by a unitary composed with complex conjugation :
Antiunitaries do occur: time reversal is antiunitary. But continuous dynamics must be unitary: a product of two antiunitaries is unitary, and each element of a continuous one-parameter group is a square, . On the Bloch sphere, unitaries act as rotations (), while antiunitaries act as orientation-reversing isometries such as reflections; complex conjugation maps .
The "universal NOT" sends every qubit pure state to its orthogonal state, i.e. reflects the Bloch sphere through its center. What does Wigner's theorem say about it?
- It is the unitary
- It is antiunitary (), so no physical device implements it exactly
- It does not preserve transition probabilities
- It is the unitary , up to a global phase
Show the answer
B. It is antiunitary (), so no physical device implements it exactly
The point reflection preserves but has determinant , so it is not a rotation; Wigner forces it to be antiunitary. Explicitly maps to , which is orthogonal to the input. Only approximate versions exist, with optimal fidelity .
Geometry in motion: speed limits and geometric phase
Curves in have lengths, so dynamics has a speed. Under , the speed in the FS metric is set by the energy uncertainty :
Insert into :
So the state moves through projective space at speed (Anandan & Aharonov, 1990). The distance travelled is at most the path length:
For time-independent , is conserved, and reaching an orthogonal state means covering FS distance :
Margolus and Levitin (1998) proved a complementary bound in terms of the mean energy above the ground energy . Both are tight for an equal superposition of two energy levels:
Closed loops carry a second geometric quantity. Transport a state around a loop in while keeping (no local phase change) and it returns multiplied by the holonomy of the Hopf bundle, the Aharonov–Anandan geometric phase. For a qubit its magnitude is half the solid angle enclosed on the Bloch sphere, independent of how fast the loop is traversed (see Geometric (Berry) Phase).
Key takeaways
- Pure states are rays: the state space of is , of real dimension ; for a qubit the Hopf fibration quotients out the global phase.
- Global phase is unobservable, but a conditional phase is relative and measurable (phase kickback).
- The Fubini–Study distance is half the Bloch angle, with and .
- Wigner: symmetries of rays are unitary or antiunitary; continuous dynamics is unitary, and the universal NOT is not physical.
- States move at FS speed , which gives the Mandelstam–Tamm bound .
Check yourself
In the interactive lesson these are scored with your confidence, and what you miss comes back for review.
What is the real dimension of the pure-state space of qubits?
Show the answer
C.
has real dimensions; normalization removes one and global phase another, so . For that is , the Bloch sphere.
What is the Fubini–Study distance between two orthogonal pure states?
Show the answer
D.
, the maximum. In this metric the Bloch sphere has radius , and orthogonal states are antipodal: half a great circle of circumference .
A qubit evolves under a time-independent Hamiltonian, and its initial state has energy uncertainty . What is the shortest possible time to reach an orthogonal state?
Show the answer
A.
Mandelstam–Tamm: , attained by the resonant -pulse.
For unit vectors , which of these is not a function of the ray alone?
- The complex number
- The projector
Show the answer
C. The complex number
Replacing by multiplies by . Probabilities, expectation values and are phase-invariant. Ratios such as are ray invariants: they are the projective coordinates on that encode the relative phase.
Further reading
- I. Bengtsson & K. Życzkowski, Geometry of Quantum States: An Introduction to Quantum Entanglement (Cambridge, 2nd ed., 2017).
- V. Bargmann, "Note on Wigner's theorem on symmetry operations," J. Math. Phys. 5, 862 (1964).
- J. Anandan & Y. Aharonov, "Geometry of quantum evolution," Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 1697 (1990).
- L. Mandelstam & I. Tamm, "The uncertainty relation between energy and time in non-relativistic quantum mechanics," J. Phys. USSR 9 (1945).
- N. Margolus & L. B. Levitin, "The maximum speed of dynamical evolution," Physica D 120, 188 (1998).