Simple Algorithm
Quantum Computing · Rydberg State · 30 min

Geometric (Berry) Phase

Phase from the shape of a path, not its duration.

Carry a spin slowly around a closed loop and it comes back with an extra phase that depends only on the shape of the loop: minus half the solid angle it enclosed. Berry's phase is the simplest example of a holonomy, and it reappears in topological band theory and in geometric quantum gates.

What you’ll learn

  • Derive γn(C)=i∮C⟨n∣∇Rn⟩⋅dR\gamma_n(C)=i\oint_C\braket{n|\nabla_{\mathbf R}n}\cdot d\mathbf R from the adiabatic theorem and prove it is gauge invariant modulo 2π2\pi.
  • Compute γ=−Ω/2\gamma=-\Omega/2 for a spin-½ following a field, and the Chern number of that eigenstate bundle.
  • Generalize to non-adiabatic cyclic evolutions (Aharonov–Anandan) and to discrete paths (the Bargmann invariant).
  • Split a total phase into dynamical and geometric parts, and use that split to design a purely geometric gate.

Where the extra phase comes from

Let a Hamiltonian H(R)H(\mathbf R) depend on parameters R\mathbf R, say a magnetic-field vector, and let ∣n(R)⟩\ket{n(\mathbf R)} be a nondegenerate eigenstate with energy En(R)E_n(\mathbf R), separated by a gap from the rest of the spectrum. Move R(t)\mathbf R(t) slowly around a closed loop CC in total time TT. The adiabatic theorem says the state stays in the instantaneous eigenspace (with error O(1/T)\order{1/T} for smooth paths), so the only freedom left is a phase.

DerivationBerry's phase from the Schrödinger equation (ħ = 1)
  1. ∣ψ(t)⟩=eiγn(t) e−i∫0tEn(t′) dt′ ∣n(R(t))⟩\ket{\psi(t)}=e^{i\gamma_n(t)}\,e^{-i\int_0^tE_n(t')\,dt'}\,\ket{n(\mathbf R(t))}

    Adiabatic ansatz: the dynamical phase, plus an unknown extra phase γn(t)\gamma_n(t).

  2. i∂t∣ψ⟩=H∣ψ⟩  ⟹  −γ˙n∣n⟩+i∣∂tn⟩≈0i\partial_t\ket\psi=H\ket\psi\;\Longrightarrow\;-\dot\gamma_n\ket n+i\ket{\partial_tn}\approx0

    Insert into the Schrödinger equation; the EnE_n terms cancel. The components of ∣∂tn⟩\ket{\partial_tn} outside ∣n⟩\ket n are the non-adiabatic transitions neglected here.

  3. γ˙n=i⟨n∣∂tn⟩=i⟨n∣∇Rn⟩⋅R˙\dot\gamma_n=i\braket{n|\partial_tn}=i\braket{n|\nabla_{\mathbf R}n}\cdot\dot{\mathbf R}

    Project onto ⟨n∣\bra n. Since ⟨n∣n⟩=1\braket{n|n}=1, ⟨n∣∂tn⟩\braket{n|\partial_tn} is purely imaginary, so γn\gamma_n is real.

  4. γn(C)=∮CAn⋅dR,An(R)=i⟨n∣∇Rn⟩\gamma_n(C)=\oint_C\mathbf A_n\cdot d\mathbf R,\qquad\mathbf A_n(\mathbf R)=i\braket{n|\nabla_{\mathbf R}n}

    Integrate over one cycle. Time has dropped out: γn\gamma_n depends on the path, not on the speed. An\mathbf A_n is the Berry connection.

Spin-½: minus half the solid angle

Take H=−ω02 n^⋅σ⃗H=-\tfrac{\omega_0}{2}\,\hat n\cdot\vec\sigma with n^(θ,φ)\hat n(\theta,\varphi) on the unit sphere: a spin in a field of fixed strength whose direction you steer. The ground state is the spin aligned with the field, ∣ψ⟩=cos⁡θ2∣0⟩+eiφsin⁡θ2∣1⟩\ket{\psi}=\cos\tfrac\theta2\ket0+e^{i\varphi}\sin\tfrac\theta2\ket1, whose Bloch vector is n^\hat n.

Derivationγ = −Ω/2
  1. ⟨ψ∣∂θψ⟩=0,⟨ψ∣∂φψ⟩=isin⁡2θ2\braket{\psi|\partial_\theta\psi}=0,\qquad\braket{\psi|\partial_\varphi\psi}=i\sin^2\tfrac\theta2

    Differentiate the Bloch parametrization.

  2. A⋅dR=i⟨ψ∣∂φψ⟩ dφ=−sin⁡2θ2 dφ\mathbf A\cdot d\mathbf R=i\braket{\psi|\partial_\varphi\psi}\,d\varphi=-\sin^2\tfrac\theta2\,d\varphi

    Only the φ\varphi component survives. This gauge is smooth everywhere except the south pole, where eiφ∣1⟩e^{i\varphi}\ket1 is multivalued.

  3. γ(Cθ)=−∫02πsin⁡2θ2 dφ=−π(1−cos⁡θ)\gamma(C_\theta)=-\int_0^{2\pi}\sin^2\tfrac\theta2\,d\varphi=-\pi(1-\cos\theta)

    Integrate around the circle of latitude θ\theta, traversed with φ\varphi increasing.

  4. γ(C)=−12 Ω(C),Ω(Cθ)=2π(1−cos⁡θ)\gamma(C)=-\tfrac12\,\Omega(C),\qquad\Omega(C_\theta)=2\pi(1-\cos\theta)

    2π(1−cos⁡θ)2\pi(1-\cos\theta) is the solid angle of the polar cap. Letting the field magnitude vary too, R∈R3∖{0}\mathbf R\in\R^3\setminus\{0\}, the curvature is F=−R^/(2R2)\mathbf F=-\hat{\mathbf R}/(2R^2): a monopole of strength −12-\tfrac12 at the degeneracy R=0\mathbf R=0. By Stokes the formula holds for every loop.

Check your understanding

A spin adiabatically follows a field that sweeps once around the equator. Ignoring the dynamical phase, what factor eiγe^{i\gamma} does the aligned state pick up?

  1. +1+1
  2. ii
  3. −1-1
  4. It depends on the sweep speed
Show the answer

C. −1-1

The equator encloses a hemisphere, Ω=2π\Omega=2\pi, so γ=−π\gamma=-\pi and eiγ=−1e^{i\gamma}=-1, whichever cap you use.

Without adiabaticity: Aharonov–Anandan and Pancharatnam

Adiabaticity is not essential. Aharonov and Anandan (1987) noticed that any cyclic evolution, ∣ψ(T)⟩=eiΦ∣ψ(0)⟩\ket{\psi(T)}=e^{i\Phi}\ket{\psi(0)}, traces a closed curve in projective space, and the part of Φ\Phi not accounted for by energy is geometric:

β=Φ+1ℏ∫0T⟨ψ(t)|H(t)|ψ(t)⟩ dtdepends only on the closed curve in CP1≅S2\beta=\Phi+\frac1\hbar\int_0^T\mel{\psi(t)}{H(t)}{\psi(t)}\,dt\quad\text{depends only on the closed curve in }\C P^1\cong S^2
For a qubit, β=−12Ω\beta=-\tfrac12\Omega, where Ω\Omega is the solid angle swept by the Bloch vector itself. This is Berry's result with the state, rather than the field, tracing the loop.
DerivationCheck: one full precession of a tilted spin
  1. H=ℏω2Z,T=2πω,U(T)=e−iπZ=−IH=\tfrac{\hbar\omega}{2}Z,\qquad T=\tfrac{2\pi}{\omega},\qquad U(T)=e^{-i\pi Z}=-\id

    Precess a state with polar angle θ\theta once around zz.

  2. Φ=−π\Phi=-\pi

    The total phase is the double-cover sign, the same for every state.

  3. −1ℏ∫0T⟨H⟩ dt=−ω2cos⁡θ⋅2πω=−πcos⁡θ-\frac1\hbar\int_0^T\expval H\,dt=-\frac\omega2\cos\theta\cdot\frac{2\pi}{\omega}=-\pi\cos\theta

    The dynamical phase, using ⟨Z⟩=cos⁡θ\expval Z=\cos\theta.

  4. β=−π+πcos⁡θ=−π(1−cos⁡θ)=−12 Ω\beta=-\pi+\pi\cos\theta=-\pi(1-\cos\theta)=-\tfrac12\,\Omega

    Geometric phase = total phase minus dynamical phase, matching the solid angle of the cap the Bloch vector circles. The −I-\id of the double cover splits into a geometric part and a dynamical part.

Predict before you look

Carry a qubit along geodesics ∣0⟩→∣+⟩→∣+i⟩→∣0⟩\ket0\to\ket+\to\ket{+i}\to\ket0, the octant triangle z^→x^→y^\hat z\to\hat x\to\hat y. What is the magnitude of its geometric phase, in degrees?

Show the answer

45 °

The triangle covers one octant, Ω=4π/8=π/2\Omega=4\pi/8=\pi/2, so ∣γ∣=Ω/2=45∘\abs\gamma=\Omega/2=45^\circ. With amplitudes: ⟨0∣+⟩⟨+∣+i⟩⟨+i∣0⟩=12⋅1+i2⋅12=1+i4\braket{0|+}\braket{+|{+i}}\braket{{+i}|0}=\tfrac1{\sqrt2}\cdot\tfrac{1+i}{2}\cdot\tfrac1{\sqrt2}=\tfrac{1+i}{4}, whose argument is 45∘45^\circ.

Geometric gates, and the frontier

A phase fixed by the path is insensitive to how fast the path is traversed. The octant loop makes this concrete. Ry(π2)R_y(\tfrac\pi2), then Rz(π2)R_z(\tfrac\pi2), then Rx(π2)R_x(\tfrac\pi2) carries ∣0⟩→∣+⟩→∣+i⟩→∣0⟩\ket0\to\ket+\to\ket{+i}\to\ket0, each step a quarter great circle about an axis perpendicular to the Bloch vector, so ⟨H⟩=0\expval H=0 throughout and no dynamical phase accrues. The net result is e−iπ/4∣0⟩e^{-i\pi/4}\ket0: a purely geometric phase. Make the rotations conditional on a control qubit and that phase is kicked back where you can see it.

Key takeaways

  • Adiabatic transport around a loop adds γn(C)=∮An⋅dR\gamma_n(C)=\oint\mathbf A_n\cdot d\mathbf R, with An=i⟨n∣∇n⟩\mathbf A_n=i\braket{n|\nabla n}: independent of speed, gauge invariant modulo 2π2\pi, equal to the flux of the Berry curvature.
  • For spin-½, γ=−Ω/2\gamma=-\Omega/2: the curvature is a monopole of strength −12-\tfrac12 at the degeneracy, and the Chern number is an integer.
  • Aharonov–Anandan: for any cyclic evolution, total phase = dynamical phase + geometric phase, and for a qubit the geometric part is −Ω/2-\Omega/2 of the Bloch-vector loop.
  • Discretely, arg⁡⟨ψ1∣ψ2⟩⟨ψ2∣ψ3⟩⟨ψ3∣ψ1⟩=Ω/2\arg\braket{\psi_1|\psi_2}\braket{\psi_2|\psi_3}\braket{\psi_3|\psi_1}=\Omega/2 for the geodesic triangle; the octant loop gives a 45∘45^\circ phase.
  • Geometric phases underlie topological band invariants and geometric or holonomic gates, whose robustness depends on the noise.

Check yourself

In the interactive lesson these are scored with your confidence, and what you miss comes back for review.

Question 1

You traverse the same loop CC twice as slowly. What happens to the dynamical phase ∫En dt\int E_n\,dt and to the Berry phase?

  1. Both double
  2. Dynamical phase unchanged; Berry phase halves
  3. Dynamical phase doubles; Berry phase unchanged
  4. Both are unchanged
Show the answer

C. Dynamical phase doubles; Berry phase unchanged

∫0TEn dt\int_0^TE_n\,dt grows with the duration, while γn(C)=∮An⋅dR\gamma_n(C)=\oint\mathbf A_n\cdot d\mathbf R is a line integral over the path, independent of its parametrization.

Question 2

Under ∣n⟩→eiχ(R)∣n⟩\ket n\to e^{i\chi(\mathbf R)}\ket n with eiχe^{i\chi} smooth and single valued, how does the Berry phase of a closed loop change?

  1. By an integer multiple of 2π2\pi
  2. By χ(Rend)−χ(Rstart)\chi(\mathbf R_{\rm end})-\chi(\mathbf R_{\rm start}), an arbitrary real number
  3. It is multiplied by eiχe^{i\chi}
  4. It flips sign
Show the answer

A. By an integer multiple of 2π2\pi

A→A−∇χ\mathbf A\to\mathbf A-\nabla\chi, so γ→γ−∮∇χ⋅dR\gamma\to\gamma-\oint\nabla\chi\cdot d\mathbf R. Since eiχe^{i\chi} is single valued, χ\chi can only wind by 2πk2\pi k around the loop, so eiγe^{i\gamma} is invariant.

Question 3

A spin-½ adiabatically follows a field around a loop enclosing solid angle Ω=π/3\Omega=\pi/3. What are the Berry phases of the aligned and the anti-aligned states?

  1. −π/3-\pi/3 and +π/3+\pi/3
  2. −π/6-\pi/6 for both
  3. −π/12-\pi/12 and +π/12+\pi/12
  4. −π/6-\pi/6 and +π/6+\pi/6
Show the answer

D. −π/6-\pi/6 and +π/6+\pi/6

γm=−mΩ\gamma_m=-m\Omega with m=±12m=\pm\tfrac12 gives ∓π/6\mp\pi/6. The two eigenstates see opposite curvature: monopoles of strength ∓12\mp\tfrac12.

Question 4

A qubit undergoes a cyclic evolution with total phase Φ\Phi and dynamical phase δ=−1ℏ∫⟨H⟩ dt\delta=-\tfrac1\hbar\int\expval H\,dt, while its Bloch vector encloses solid angle Ω\Omega. Which relation holds modulo 2π2\pi?

  1. Φ=δ\Phi=\delta
  2. Φ=δ−Ω/2\Phi=\delta-\Omega/2
  3. Φ=−Ω/2\Phi=-\Omega/2, always
  4. Φ=δ+Ω\Phi=\delta+\Omega
Show the answer

B. Φ=δ−Ω/2\Phi=\delta-\Omega/2

Aharonov–Anandan: total = dynamical + geometric, with geometric part −Ω/2-\Omega/2 for a qubit, and no adiabaticity needed. In the precession example Φ=−π\Phi=-\pi, δ=−πcos⁡θ\delta=-\pi\cos\theta and Ω=2π(1−cos⁡θ)\Omega=2\pi(1-\cos\theta).

Further reading

  • M. V. Berry, Quantal phase factors accompanying adiabatic changes, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A (1984).
  • B. Simon, Holonomy, the quantum adiabatic theorem, and Berry's phase, Physical Review Letters (1983).
  • Y. Aharonov & J. Anandan, Phase change during a cyclic quantum evolution, Physical Review Letters (1987).
  • J. Samuel & R. Bhandari, General setting for Berry's phase, Physical Review Letters (1988).
  • P. Zanardi & M. Rasetti, Holonomic quantum computation, Physics Letters A (1999).