Photons, Spins & Topological Qubits
Light-based computing, silicon spins and topological protection.
Three very different bets on quantum hardware share this lesson. Photons barely interact with anything, which makes them perfect messengers and frustrating logic gates. Electron spins in silicon ride on the chip industry's manufacturing machine. Topological qubits would hide information from noise altogether, if the exotic quasiparticles they need can be shown to exist.
What you’ll learn
- Describe polarization, dual-rail and time-bin photonic qubits, and compute the action of beam splitters and phase shifters.
- Explain why photonic two-qubit gates are probabilistic, using Hong–Ou–Mandel interference and the KLM scheme.
- Outline measurement- and fusion-based photonic computing with cluster states.
- Derive the exchange interaction between quantum-dot spins, and name the main decoherence sources in silicon.
- Explain how Majorana zero modes would encode a qubit non-locally, why braiding gives only Clifford gates, and what the experimental status is.
Qubits made of light
A photon can carry a qubit in several degrees of freedom:
- Polarization: and . Easy to control with wave plates; natural for free-space links.
- Path (dual-rail): one photon in two waveguides, (upper) or (lower). The workhorse of integrated photonic chips.
- Time bin: early or late arrival, or . Robust in optical fiber, where polarization drifts.
All three are dual-rail codes: one photon shared between two optical modes. Losing the photon leaves zero photons, a state outside the code space, so loss is detectable by counting photons.
Single-qubit gates are linear optics. A phase shifter on one mode applies , a -type rotation. A balanced (50:50) beam splitter mixes the two modes:
A dual-rail photonic qubit loses its photon in a lossy waveguide. What do the detectors see, and why is that useful?
- A random qubit value: loss acts like a bit flip you cannot detect
- Two photons, because loss creates a photon in the other rail
- No photon at all, a state outside the code space, so the loss is heralded and can be treated as an erasure
- The same statistics as before: loss does not affect photonic qubits
Show the answer
C. No photon at all, a state outside the code space, so the loss is heralded and can be treated as an erasure
Loss maps and to , which no valid codeword produces. An error at a known location (an erasure) is far easier to correct than an unknown flip.
Making photons interact without interaction
Photons pass through each other, and optical nonlinearities at the single-photon level are extremely weak in ordinary materials. A deterministic two-photon gate would need such a nonlinearity, so photonic computing uses a different resource: measurement. The key ingredient is two-photon interference.
A balanced beam splitter maps the creation operators of the input modes to those of the output modes .
Two identical photons, one in each input. Bosonic creation operators commute, so the cross terms cancel.
Using . The photons always leave together: the coincidence rate vanishes.
Think first What happens if the two photons are perfectly distinguishable, say orthogonally polarized, with polarization-blind detectors?
No interference: each photon transmits or reflects independently, and they leave through different ports half the time (). The depth of the "HOM dip" in the coincidence rate therefore measures how indistinguishable two photons are, a key benchmark for photon sources.
HOM interference is a conditional effect: what one photon does depends on the other, through their indistinguishability. Knill, Laflamme and Milburn (2001) showed that auxiliary photons, photon-number-resolving detectors and feed-forward (adapting later optics to earlier detection results) suffice for universal, scalable quantum computing. The price is that gates succeed only with some probability, heralded by the detectors: KLM's basic controlled- succeeds with probability , and teleporting gates into the circuit boosts this toward 1 at the cost of more photons.
Computing by measuring
Probabilistic gates are awkward inside a circuit: one failure can ruin the computation. Measurement-based quantum computing (Raussendorf & Briegel, 2001) separates entangling from computing. First build a large entangled cluster state: put every qubit in and apply CZ between neighbors on a graph. Then compute using only single-qubit measurements, choosing each basis according to earlier outcomes. Entanglement can be made offline, by trial and error, and only finished resources are consumed.
Photonic architectures grow cluster states from small entangled states by fusion, a two-photon Bell-type measurement that merges two clusters into one (Browne & Rudolph, 2005). Basic fusions succeed with probability , but failures are heralded, so the architecture can route around them. Fusion-based quantum computing (Bartolucci et al., 2023) makes this the organizing principle of a fault-tolerant design.
Spin qubits in silicon
A spin qubit stores information in the spin of a single electron (or hole) confined in a semiconductor quantum dot, a small puddle of charge defined by voltages on nanoscale gate electrodes, or bound to a donor atom such as phosphorus in silicon. In a magnetic field the spin states split by the Zeeman energy , about 28 GHz per tesla for , so fields of a fraction of a tesla give qubit frequencies of several to tens of GHz.
Single-qubit gates use electron spin resonance (an oscillating magnetic field) or, more often, electric-dipole spin resonance: an oscillating electric field shakes the electron in the field gradient of a micromagnet, or acts through spin–orbit coupling. Readout uses spin-to-charge conversion: a spin-dependent tunneling event moves a charge that a nearby sensor detects.
Two neighboring dots with one electron each, tunnel coupling and on-site Coulomb repulsion : a two-site Hubbard model.
Hopping into a doubly occupied dot requires opposite spins in the same orbital, a singlet. The Pauli principle blocks the triplets.
Second-order perturbation theory: virtual hops into each doubly occupied state lower the singlet.
The singlet–triplet splitting is an effective exchange interaction. Gate voltages tune by orders of magnitude within nanoseconds, switching on and off.
Exchange makes two-qubit gates. Since , an exchange pulse with gives , which together with single-spin rotations is universal (Loss & DiVincenzo, 1998). With a large Zeeman-energy difference between the dots (from a micromagnet), exchange instead produces a controlled phase, and gives a CZ.
Two dots have tunnel coupling μeV and charging energy meV. Estimate the exchange in MHz, using MHz.
Show the answer
12 MHz
, i.e. MHz. A CZ in the large-Zeeman-difference regime then takes ns. Because and depends exponentially on the barrier-gate voltage, can be switched over orders of magnitude.
Two-qubit fidelities above 99% were reported in silicon by several groups in 2022, and spin-qubit devices have been fabricated on industrial 300-mm lines. The remaining challenges are uniformity, wiring and the charge environment.
Topological qubits: hiding information in Majoranas
Every platform so far fights noise with error correction applied from outside. A topological qubit would build protection into the hardware by storing information non-locally, where no local disturbance can read or change it.
The proposed carriers are Majorana zero modes (MZMs): zero-energy excitations bound to the ends of a one-dimensional topological superconductor. A Majorana operator is its own adjoint, with . Two MZMs , possibly far apart, together form one ordinary fermion mode , which can be empty or occupied at no energy cost. Its occupation, the fermion parity , is stored in the pair as a whole, not at either end.
Braiding (exchanging) two MZMs applies to the qubit space. These operations depend only on the topology of the exchange, which is the source of their robustness. But they generate only Clifford gates: universality still needs a non-Clifford resource such as magic states, prepared outside the topological protection.
Exchanging and applies to the qubit, where . Up to a global phase, which gate is that?
- , a gate
- or , a Clifford phase gate
- , a Hadamard
- The identity
Show the answer
B. or , a Clifford phase gate
: a quarter turn about , a Clifford gate (the orientation of the exchange decides between and ). No braid of Majoranas produces .
Key takeaways
- Photonic qubits are dual-rail codes: beam splitters and phase shifters give any single-qubit gate, and loss is the dominant but detectable error.
- Photons do not interact, so entangling operations are measurement-induced and probabilistic (KLM; Bell measurements at most 50% efficient without ancillas), which favors measurement- and fusion-based architectures.
- Spin qubits use electrons in quantum dots; exchange gives fast two-qubit gates, and coherence is limited by nuclear spins (cured by Si), charge noise and valley physics.
- Majorana zero modes would store a qubit non-locally in fermion parity; braiding gives only Clifford gates, and an unambiguous demonstration of MZMs and braiding is still outstanding.
Check yourself
In the interactive lesson these are scored with your confidence, and what you miss comes back for review.
A dual-rail photon passes a balanced beam splitter (acting as ), a phase shift on one arm, and a second identical beam splitter. Where does it exit?
- Always at the first output (D0)
- Always at the second output (D1)
- 50/50 at random
- It depends on the photon's polarization
Show the answer
B. Always at the second output (D1)
: the phase shift is a gate between two Hadamards, which flips the dual-rail qubit. .
Why can't linear optics alone perform a deterministic Bell-state measurement on two photonic qubits?
- Photons are destroyed by detection
- Beam splitters are too lossy
- Bell states of photons do not exist
- With beam splitters, phase shifters and photon counting (no auxiliary photons), at most two of the four Bell states can be distinguished, so success is at most ½
Show the answer
D. With beam splitters, phase shifters and photon counting (no auxiliary photons), at most two of the four Bell states can be distinguished, so success is at most ½
Bosonic interference sorts and into distinct click patterns, but and give identical ones. Calsamiglia and Lütkenhaus (2001) proved no linear network does better without ancillas.
In measurement-based quantum computing, where does the computation happen?
- In adaptive single-qubit measurements on a pre-built entangled cluster state
- In the CZ gates that build the cluster state
- In one final joint measurement of all qubits
- In the classical post-processing alone
Show the answer
A. In adaptive single-qubit measurements on a pre-built entangled cluster state
The cluster state is a fixed, algorithm-independent resource. The choice of single-qubit measurement bases, adapted to earlier outcomes, encodes the algorithm.
Why does isotopic enrichment to Si improve spin-qubit coherence?
- It increases the electron's g-factor
- It enlarges the valley splitting
- It removes most spinful Si nuclei, whose fluctuating hyperfine field dephases the electron spin
- It eliminates charge noise
Show the answer
C. It removes most spinful Si nuclei, whose fluctuating hyperfine field dephases the electron spin
Si has no nuclear spin. Removing Si shrinks the random Overhauser field and lengthens , until charge noise becomes the limit.
Why does a Majorana qubit need four zero modes rather than two?
- Fermion-parity superselection forbids superposing the even and odd states of one pair, so the qubit uses two pairs at fixed total parity
- Two Majoranas cannot be separated
- Each Majorana carries half a qubit, so four make two qubits
- Braiding needs at least four modes to do anything
Show the answer
A. Fermion-parity superselection forbids superposing the even and odd states of one pair, so the qubit uses two pairs at fixed total parity
One pair's two states differ in fermion parity and cannot be superposed. Two pairs at fixed total parity span a genuine two-dimensional qubit space.
Go deeper
- Linear Optical QC & Fusion · KLM, measurement-induced nonlinearity and fusion-based designs.
- Spin Qubits in Semiconductors · Electrons in quantum dots, and riding the chip industry.
- Topological Qubits & Majorana Modes · Encoding information non-locally in exotic quasiparticles.
Further reading
- P. Kok, W. J. Munro, K. Nemoto, T. C. Ralph, J. P. Dowling & G. J. Milburn, "Linear optical quantum computing with photonic qubits", Reviews of Modern Physics 79, 135 (2007).
- E. Knill, R. Laflamme & G. J. Milburn, "A scheme for efficient quantum computation with linear optics", Nature 409, 46 (2001).
- G. Burkard, T. D. Ladd, A. Pan, J. M. Nichol & J. R. Petta, "Semiconductor spin qubits", Reviews of Modern Physics 95, 025003 (2023).
- C. Nayak, S. H. Simon, A. Stern, M. Freedman & S. Das Sarma, "Non-Abelian anyons and topological quantum computation", Reviews of Modern Physics 80, 1083 (2008).