The Rydberg Blockade
Giant atoms that forbid their neighbors from exciting.
A rubidium atom excited to is a few tenths of a micrometer across, and it interacts with a similar neighbor more strongly than ground-state atoms do by many orders of magnitude. Within several micrometers, one excited atom shifts every other one out of resonance. This blockade is the entangling mechanism of neutral-atom quantum computers.
What you’ll learn
- Derive the scaling laws of Rydberg atoms and the origin of the interaction in dipole–dipole coupling.
- State and prove the blockade theorem for atoms, including the collective enhancement.
- Prove when a diagonal two-qubit phase gate equals CZ up to local rotations, and apply it to Jaksch-type and global-pulse protocols.
- Derive the intrinsic error budget of a blockade gate and its optimum, .
Rydberg atoms by the numbers
Rydberg states are hydrogen-like, with an effective principal quantum number , where the quantum defect accounts for the penetrable ionic core. Their properties follow hydrogenic scalings.
| Property | Scaling | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Binding energy | Weakly bound and easily perturbed | |
| Orbital radius | A few tenths of a μm at | |
| Dipole moment to neighboring levels | Huge transition dipoles between Rydberg states | |
| Spacing of neighboring levels | Microwave-frequency transitions | |
| Radiative lifetime | at zero temperature | Of order 100 μs at room temperature for , where blackbody radiation shortens it |
| Polarizability | Strong sensitivity to stray electric fields | |
| Van der Waals | MHz-scale interactions at several μm |
Two atoms in the same Rydberg state couple through the dipole–dipole interaction to pair states of opposite parity.
Keep the most strongly coupled pair state; is its energy offset (the Förster defect), and .
Exact eigenvalues of the two-level pair model.
At long range the shift of the branch connected to is second order: van der Waals, with a sign set by . At short range, , the states mix fully and the interaction becomes resonant dipole–dipole, . Electric fields can tune to zero (a Förster resonance), giving interactions at all distances.
The blockade theorem
The speed-up for two atoms was observed by Gaëtan et al. (2009) and is now a standard calibration of the blockade. A blockaded ensemble behaves as one "superatom", the basis of Rydberg quantum optics. For computing, the key consequence is conditional dynamics: whether an atom can be excited depends on whether its neighbor already is.
From blockade to a CZ gate
Jaksch et al. (2000). A π-pulse on the control, a -pulse on the target and another π-pulse on the control give , so the invariant is : a CZ. The blockade enters only through , since the target's -pulse is suppressed while the control sits in . Two features make the scheme robust: the exact value of is irrelevant as long as , and the atoms need not sit at precisely defined distances.
Global protocols. Levine et al. (2019) drove both atoms with the same two pulses, separated by a jump of the laser phase. The inputs and then undergo single-atom dynamics at , while undergoes blockaded dynamics between and at . Pulse length, detuning and phase jump are chosen so that both return to the qubit subspace with : a CZ up to single-qubit phases, by the theorem. Evered et al. (2023) used smooth, time-optimal phase-modulated pulses (Jandura & Pupillo, 2022) and reported CZ fidelities of about 99.5%, applied in parallel to up to 60 atoms.
A calibrated Rydberg gate produces the phases and . Up to single-qubit rotations, it is
- the identity: no entanglement
- a controlled phase of
- a CZ
- a controlled phase of
Show the answer
C. a CZ
The invariant is , so the gate is a CZ dressed with local rotations, exactly the structure of the global-pulse protocols.
The error budget of a blockade gate
Even with perfect lasers, a blockade gate has two intrinsic errors that pull in opposite directions. Time spent in risks decay (lifetime ), which argues for a strong, fast drive; but a strong drive leaks into the doubly excited state, shifted by the blockade frequency , which argues for a weak one. Saffman and Walker (2005) analyzed this trade-off for the Jaksch protocol; here are its two leading terms.
Average time spent in over the four inputs. : never. : half of a -pulse, . and : half of each control π-pulse ( twice) plus the full in between, .
Decay probability, to first order.
During the target's -pulse with the control in , off-resonant excitation of (detuning ) leaves a time-averaged population of about , and only one of the four inputs is affected. (A further term, from off-resonant excitation of the other qubit level, depends on the qubit frequency and is omitted.)
Minimize over by setting .
At the optimum the decay term is twice the blockade term. The intrinsic error falls only as the power of the figure of merit .
With a blockade shift MHz and a Rydberg lifetime μs, estimate the minimum intrinsic error of a Jaksch gate, in percent.
Show the answer
0.3 %
and , so , about 0.3%, at an optimal MHz. An intrinsic floor at the level is why reaching 99.9% needs better protocols as well as longer-lived, more strongly interacting states.
| Technical error | Mechanism | Mitigation |
|---|---|---|
| Doppler dephasing | Thermal velocity gives the ground–Rydberg coherence a random phase ; for two-photon excitation at ~10 μK, is a few μs | Colder atoms; counter-propagating beams to minimize ; short gates |
| Laser phase noise | Noise at Fourier frequencies near drives errors directly | Spectral filtering of the excitation lasers with optical cavities |
| Intermediate-state scattering | Two-photon excitation through a short-lived state scatters photons | Large intermediate detuning, at the cost of laser power |
| Intensity and position fluctuations | Fluctuating changes rotation angles; positions matter little deep in the blockade regime | Beam shaping and stabilization; colder atoms |
| Leakage | Decay or blackbody transfer to other Rydberg states, or to levels outside the qubit | Leakage detection; erasure conversion (Wu, Kolkowitz, Puri & Thompson, 2022) |
Key takeaways
- Rydberg properties follow hydrogenic scalings; arises at second order from dipole–dipole coupling, crossing over to at short range.
- Perfect blockade confines atoms to , with collective Rabi frequency .
- A diagonal gate is CZ up to local rotations iff ; Jaksch and global-pulse protocols satisfy this without needing the exact value of .
- Decay and blockade leakage trade off, giving ; the best reported CZ fidelities are about 99.5% as of the mid-2020s.
Check yourself
In the interactive lesson these are scored with your confidence, and what you miss comes back for review.
Moving from to at a fixed Rabi frequency increases the blockade radius by about (ignore quantum defects)
- 1.4×
- 1.85×
- 40×
- It does not change
Show the answer
B. 1.85×
, so . itself grows by .
Why is the Jaksch gate insensitive to the exact distance between the two atoms?
- Rydberg interactions do not depend on distance
- Distance errors are removed by the single-qubit phase corrections after the gate
- The atoms are always exactly one lattice constant apart
- The ideal phases only require the doubly excited state to be far off resonance (); its exact shift does not enter
Show the answer
D. The ideal phases only require the doubly excited state to be far off resonance (); its exact shift does not enter
In the blockade limit the dynamics is "nothing happens to the target", whatever the value of . Residual errors scale as .
A better Rydberg state doubles both the blockade shift and the lifetime . The optimal intrinsic error of a Jaksch gate is multiplied by about
Show the answer
A.
and grows fourfold: .
At short distances, , the interaction between two Rydberg atoms
- vanishes
- still scales as
- scales as (resonant dipole–dipole)
- scales as
Show the answer
C. scales as (resonant dipole–dipole)
When the pair states mix completely and .
Further reading
- D. Jaksch, J. I. Cirac, P. Zoller, S. L. Rolston, R. Côté & M. D. Lukin, "Fast quantum gates for neutral atoms", Physical Review Letters 85, 2208 (2000).
- M. Saffman & T. G. Walker, "Analysis of a quantum logic device based on dipole-dipole interactions of optically trapped Rydberg atoms", Physical Review A (2005).
- H. Levine et al., "Parallel implementation of high-fidelity multiqubit gates with neutral atoms", Physical Review Letters (2019).
- S. J. Evered et al., "High-fidelity parallel entangling gates on a neutral-atom quantum computer", Nature (2023).
- M. Saffman, T. G. Walker & K. Mølmer, "Quantum information with Rydberg atoms", Reviews of Modern Physics 82, 2313 (2010).